Sunday, February 5, 2023
manilastandard.net
ADVERTISEMENT
  • About
  • News
    • Top Stories
    • National
    • World News
    • Pinoy Abroad
    • Features
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
    • Columns
    • Soundbytes
  • LGUs
    • NCR
    • Luzon
    • Visayas
    • Mindanao
  • Business
    • Corporate
    • Economy & Trade
    • Stocks
    • Money
    • Agri & Mining
    • Power & Tech
    • IT & Telecom
  • Sports
    • Basketball
    • Volleyball
    • Fightsports
    • Active
    • Sports Plus
    • One Championship
    • Columns
  • Entertainment
    • TV & Movies
    • Celebrity Profiles
    • Music & Concerts
    • Digital Media
    • Columns
  • Lifestyle
    • Food
    • Culture & Media
    • Fashion
    • Health and Home
    • Leisure
    • Shopping
    • Columns
  • Others
    • Pets
    • Pop.Life
      • Newsmakers
      • Hangouts
      • A-Pop
      • Post Its
      • Performances
      • Malls & Bazaars
      • Hobbies & Collections
    • Technology
      • Gadgets
      • Computers
      • Business
      • Tech Plus
    • MS ON THE ROAD
      • Sedan
      • SUV
      • Truck
      • Bike
      • Accessories
      • Motoring Plus
      • Commuter’s Corner
    • Home & Design
      • Residential
      • Commercial
      • Construction
      • Interior
    • Spotlight
    • Gallery
      • Photos
      • Videos
    • Events
      • Seminars
      • Exhibits
      • Community
    • Biyahero
      • Travel Features
      • Travel Reels
      • Travel Logs
  • Advertise with Us
No Result
View All Result
  • About
  • News
    • Top Stories
    • National
    • World News
    • Pinoy Abroad
    • Features
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
    • Columns
    • Soundbytes
  • LGUs
    • NCR
    • Luzon
    • Visayas
    • Mindanao
  • Business
    • Corporate
    • Economy & Trade
    • Stocks
    • Money
    • Agri & Mining
    • Power & Tech
    • IT & Telecom
  • Sports
    • Basketball
    • Volleyball
    • Fightsports
    • Active
    • Sports Plus
    • One Championship
    • Columns
  • Entertainment
    • TV & Movies
    • Celebrity Profiles
    • Music & Concerts
    • Digital Media
    • Columns
  • Lifestyle
    • Food
    • Culture & Media
    • Fashion
    • Health and Home
    • Leisure
    • Shopping
    • Columns
  • Others
    • Pets
    • Pop.Life
      • Newsmakers
      • Hangouts
      • A-Pop
      • Post Its
      • Performances
      • Malls & Bazaars
      • Hobbies & Collections
    • Technology
      • Gadgets
      • Computers
      • Business
      • Tech Plus
    • MS ON THE ROAD
      • Sedan
      • SUV
      • Truck
      • Bike
      • Accessories
      • Motoring Plus
      • Commuter’s Corner
    • Home & Design
      • Residential
      • Commercial
      • Construction
      • Interior
    • Spotlight
    • Gallery
      • Photos
      • Videos
    • Events
      • Seminars
      • Exhibits
      • Community
    • Biyahero
      • Travel Features
      • Travel Reels
      • Travel Logs
  • Advertise with Us
No Result
View All Result
manilastandard.net
No Result
View All Result
Home Opinion Columns Eagle eyes by Tony La Vina

Magnificent dissent on martial law

Tony La ViñabyTony La Viña
July 11, 2017, 12:01 am
in Eagle eyes by Tony La Vina
Reading Time: 5 mins read
A A
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on Email

As always, for columns like this, I begin with a disclosure. Associate Justice Marvic Leonen is a close friend and a long-time colleague. We met in 1985 when we were both students at the University of the Philippines College of Law and members of the UP Law Paralegal Volunteer Organization. We also co-founded a human rights and environmental law organization together. We have been colleagues at the UP Law faculty for decades.

This association with Justice Leonen does not stop me from being objective about his dissent in Lagman vs. Medialdea, the martial law decision of the Supreme Court. In fact, for the record, I am inclined toward the arguments of Justice Antonio Carpio in his concurring and dissenting opinion in Lagman where the latter limits the validity of martial law to Marawi. From the beginning, having sources on the ground and looking closely at what was happening, it was clear to me that the Maute group in Marawi was committing rebellion. They are terrorists, yes, but they are also committing rebellion and public safety imperatives could justify a martial law declaration. I think the main opinion’s dichotomy of rebellion and terrorism is wrong and I think Justice Leonen’s distinction between the two, while policy wise and politically speaking is compelling, fails technical legal scrutiny.

Having disclosed my reservations about the Leonen conclusions, let me be clear though that I think Justice Leonen has done the country a great favor with this great and magnificent dissent. I echo the words of veteran journalist Glenda Gloria who posted in Facebook: “A thought-provoking dissenting opinion. Which only deep reflection, nuanced thinking, long conversations with players on the ground, and solid commitment to peace can bring about. Thank you for this, Justice Marvic Leonen.”

The gist of the Leonen dissent is that martial law and the suspension of the writ of habeas corpus are unjustified because first, the group committing atrocities in Marawi are terrorists and not rebels. They are committing acts of terrorism and are not engaged in political acts of rebellion. Second, there is no sufficient factual basis, contrary to the submission by the respondents, to declare martial law. Third, the declaration of martial law is vague and unduly expansive. These make it unconstitutional.

On his first point, Leonen insists that the Maute group are not rebels but terrorists. They are not engaged in political acts of rebellion. In the words of Leonen “Their ideology of a nihilist apocalyptic future inspired by the extremist views of Salafi Jihadism will sway no community especially among Muslims.”

ADVERTISEMENT

For Justice Leonen, “There is no rebellion that justifies martial law. There is terrorism that requires more thoughtful action.” He points out the political consequences of recognizing the Maute terrorists as rebels: “Elevating the acts of a lawless criminal group which uses terrorism as tactic to the constitutional concept of rebellion acknowledges them as a political group. Rebellion is a political crime. We have acknowledged that if rebels are able to capture government, their rebellion, no matter how brutal, will be justified. Also, by acknowledging them as rebels, we elevate their inhuman barbarism as an “armed conflict of a non-international character” protected by International Humanitarian Law. We will be known worldwide as the only country that acknowledges them, not as criminals, but as rebels entitled to protection under international law.”

In effect, we are glorifying the Maute terrorists when we call them rebels, making them equivalent to Luis Taruc, for example, Huk rebel leader from the 1960s whom we have just raised to the status of national hero.

Leonen rightly says: “I honor the sacrifices of many by calling our enemy with their proper names: terrorists capable of committing atrocious acts. They are not rebels desirous of a viable political alternative that can be accepted by any of our societies. With their plans disrupted and with their bankrupt fanaticism for a nihilist apocalypse, they are reduced to a fighting force violently trying to escape. They are not a rebel group that can hope to achieve and hold any ground.”

On the insufficiency of factual basis to declare martial law, Justice Leonen points out: “The government’s presentation of facts and their arguments of their sufficiency are wanting. First, there are factual allegations that find no relevance to the declaration of martial law and the suspension of the privilege of the writ of habeas corpus. Second, there are facts that have been contradicted by Open-Source Intelligence sources. Lastly, there are facts that have absolutely no basis as they are unsupported by credible evidence.” For instance, respondents did not reveal their sources to support the insinuation that the ASG Basilan, AKP, Maute Group, and BIFF have vowed loyalty to the ISIS and that these groups formed an unholy alliance.

On his third argument that the Proclamation No. 216 is constitutionally vague, Leonen is of the opinion that the scope of martial law has been illegally expanded when the General Order issued to implement it included the objective “undertake all measures to prevent and suppress all acts of rebellion and lawless violence in the whole of Mindanao, including any and all acts in relation thereto, in connection therewith, or in furtherance thereof.”

Based on this, all acts of lawless violence throughout Mindanao, even if unrelated to the ongoing hostilities in Marawi, have been included in the General Order. Accordingly, the, Operational Directive for the Implementation of martial law coming from the Chief of Staff of the Armed Forces of the Philippines orders his forces to: “dismantle the NPA, other terror-linked private armed groups, illegal drug syndicates, peace spoilers and other lawless armed groups.”

Justice Leonen warns of the ghost of the Marcos dictatorship: “The government’s concept of martial law, from the broad provisions of Proclamation No. 216 therefore partakes of different senses. Rightly so, the public is not specifically guided and their rights are put at risk. This is the ghost of martial law from the Marcos era resurrected. Even Proclamation No. 1081 of September 21, 1972 was more specific than Proclamation No. 216. Yet, through subsequent executive issuances, the scope of martial law became clearer: it attempted to substitute civilian government even where there was no conflagration. It was nothing but an attempt to replace democratically elected government and civilian law enforcement with an iron hand.”

To end, let me close with Leonen’s final words, which will be quoted by many generations of law students called to recite on this great and magnificent dissent:

“We all need to fight the long war against terrorism. This needs patience, community participation, precision, and a sophisticated strategy that respects rights, and at the same time uses force decisively at the right time and in the right way. The terrorist wins when we suspend all that we believe in. The terrorist wins when we replace social justice with disempowering authoritarianism.

We should temper our fears with reason. Otherwise, we succumb to the effects of the weapons of terror. We should dissent—even resist—when offered the farce that martial law is necessary because it is ‘only an exclamation point.’”

Facebook: https://web.facebook.com/deantonylavs/ Twitter: tonylavs

Tags: Justice Marvic Leonenmartial lawMaute GroupTony La Viña
ADVERTISEMENT
Tony La Viña

Tony La Viña

Related Posts

The ICC and Duterte, the next phase

byTony La Viña
February 4, 2023, 12:05 am
0
8
Denying Villafuerte justice

"The International Criminal Court can only intervene where a State is unable or unwilling genuinely to carry out the investigation...

Read more

Victory for press freedom

byTony La Viña
January 31, 2023, 12:10 am
0
8
Denying Villafuerte justice

"May the free press win in all these cases" Rappler Holdings Corporation and its president Maria Ressa have been acquitted...

Read more

Justice delayed is justice denied (Part 2)

byTony La Viña
January 28, 2023, 12:10 am
0
8
Christmas path to peace

"The basic principle is that no one should be deprived of liberty unless there has been a trial and final...

Read more

Gigi Reyes and everyone’sright to speedy trial

byTony La Viña
January 24, 2023, 12:10 am
0
8
Denying Villafuerte justice

"The SC said while Reyes’ detention is based on a court order, her prolonged detention, without any progress on the...

Read more

Attacking human rights defenders

byTony La Viña
January 17, 2023, 12:10 am
0
8
Denying Villafuerte justice

"The story of Dyan and Armand ended well but others will not be too lucky in the future until the...

Read more

Protest, petition, passion and praise

byTony La Viña
January 14, 2023, 12:10 am
0
8

"These days, it’s San Francesco’s praise for suffering, sickness, and death—lines he added to the canticle when he became sick...

Read more

Print Edition

View More

Recent Posts

  • Villar: MIF needed for investments
  • Sta. Maria Eagles Club
  • Patiently waiting
  • NHA suspends applications at QC head office
  • Davao de Oro quake infrastructure damage hits P21 million, OCD says
  • Recto: House boosts budget for cancer treatments to P1.56 billion
  • QC solon pushes 30-day paternity leave for fathers
  • Alfonso Yuchengco: Longer than a centrury

Advertisement

Latest News

Recto: House boosts budget for cancer treatments to P1.56 billion

byRio N. Araja
February 5, 2023, 10:20 pm
0
8
No housing for police, soldiers

From zero funding in the proposed 2023 national budget, the House of Representatives has boosted to P1.56 billion the line-item...

Read more

QC solon pushes 30-day paternity leave for fathers

byRio N. Araja
February 5, 2023, 10:10 pm
0
8
QC expands free testing program for COVID-19

Quezon City Rep. Marvin Rillo is pushing for an increase in the fully paid paternity leave benefit of every working...

Read more

Alfonso Yuchengco: Longer than a centrury

byManila Standard
February 5, 2023, 10:09 pm
0
8
Alfonso Yuchengco: Longer than a centrury

On the occasion of the 100th birth anniversary of Ambassador Alfonso T. Yuchengco, February 6, 1923 - April 15, 2017...

Read more

SBMA turns over P178.7m to neighboring LGUs

byManila Standard
February 5, 2023, 10:05 pm
0
8
SBMA to release P123.1M in LGU revenue shares

SUBIC BAY FREEPORT—The Subic Bay Metropolitan Authority (SBMA) officials met with the local chief executives and representatives of this premier...

Read more

Senior Citizen party-list eyes nutrition program

byRio N. Araja
February 5, 2023, 10:00 pm
0
8
Senior Citizen party-list eyes nutrition program

Senior Citizen party-list Rep. Rodolfo Ordanes has filed a counterpart bill to Senate Bill 1799 to lay down a comprehensive...

Read more

Advertisement

ADVERTISEMENT
Facebook Twitter Instagram Youtube

ABOUT US

Manila Standard

Manila Standard website (manilastandard.net), launched in August 2002, extends the newspaper’s reach beyond its traditional readers and makes its brand of Philippine news and opinion available to a much wider and geographically diverse readership here and overseas.

Digital Edition

In tone and content, the online edition mirrors the editorial thrust of the newspaper. While hewing to the traditional precepts of fairness and objectivity, MS believes the news of the day need not be staid, overly long or dry. Stories are succinct, readable and written in a lively style that has become a hallmark of the newspaper.

Download – Today’s Paper

Search

No Result
View All Result

6th Floor Universal Re Bldg., 106 Paseo De Roxas cor. Perea Street, Legaspi Village, 1226 Makati City Philippines

Trunklines: 832-5554, 832-5556, 832-5558

© 2021 Manila Standard - Designed and Developed by Neitiviti Studios.

No Result
View All Result
  • About
  • News
    • Top Stories
    • National
    • World News
    • Pinoy Abroad
    • Features
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
    • Columns
    • Soundbytes
  • LGUs
    • NCR
    • Luzon
    • Visayas
    • Mindanao
  • Business
    • Corporate
    • Economy & Trade
    • Stocks
    • Money
    • Agri & Mining
    • Power & Tech
    • IT & Telecom
  • Sports
    • Basketball
    • Volleyball
    • Fightsports
    • Active
    • Sports Plus
    • One Championship
    • Columns
  • Entertainment
    • TV & Movies
    • Celebrity Profiles
    • Music & Concerts
    • Digital Media
    • Columns
  • Lifestyle
    • Food
    • Culture & Media
    • Fashion
    • Health and Home
    • Leisure
    • Shopping
    • Columns
  • Pop.Life
    • Newsmakers
    • Hangouts
    • A-Pop
    • Post Its
    • Performances
    • Malls & Bazaars
    • Hobbies & Collections
  • Technology
    • Gadgets
    • Computers
    • Business
    • Tech Plus
  • MS ON THE ROAD
    • Sedan
    • SUV
    • Truck
    • Bike
    • Accessories
    • Motoring Plus
    • Commuter’s Corner
  • Home & Design
    • Residential
    • Commercial
    • Construction
    • Interior
  • Spotlight
  • Gallery
    • Photos
    • Videos
  • Events
    • Seminars
    • Exhibits
    • Community
  • Biyahero
    • Travel Features
    • Travel Reels
    • Travel Logs
  • Pets
  • Advertise with Us

© 2021 Manila Standard - Designed and Developed by Neitiviti Studios.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Install Manila Standard Web App

Install App