Tuesday, June 28, 2022
manilastandard.net
ADVERTISEMENT
  • About
  • News
    • Top Stories
    • National
    • World News
    • Pinoy Abroad
    • Features
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
    • Columns
    • Soundbytes
  • LGUs
    • NCR
    • Luzon
    • Visayas
    • Mindanao
  • Business
    • Corporate
    • Economy & Trade
    • Stocks
    • Money
    • Agri & Mining
    • Power & Tech
    • IT & Telecom
  • Sports
    • Basketball
    • Volleyball
    • Fightsports
    • Active
    • Sports Plus
    • One Championship
    • Columns
  • Entertainment
    • TV & Movies
    • Celebrity Profiles
    • Music & Concerts
    • Digital Media
    • Columns
  • Lifestyle
    • Food
    • Culture & Media
    • Fashion
    • Health and Home
    • Leisure
    • Shopping
    • Columns
  • Others
    • Pets
    • Pop.Life
      • Newsmakers
      • Hangouts
      • A-Pop
      • Post Its
      • Performances
      • Malls & Bazaars
      • Hobbies & Collections
    • Technology
      • Gadgets
      • Computers
      • Business
      • Tech Plus
    • MS ON THE ROAD
      • Sedan
      • SUV
      • Truck
      • Bike
      • Accessories
      • Motoring Plus
      • Commuter’s Corner
    • Home & Design
      • Residential
      • Commercial
      • Construction
      • Interior
    • Spotlight
    • Gallery
      • Photos
      • Videos
    • Events
      • Seminars
      • Exhibits
      • Community
    • Biyahero
      • Travel Features
      • Travel Reels
      • Travel Logs
  • Advertise with Us
No Result
View All Result
  • About
  • News
    • Top Stories
    • National
    • World News
    • Pinoy Abroad
    • Features
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
    • Columns
    • Soundbytes
  • LGUs
    • NCR
    • Luzon
    • Visayas
    • Mindanao
  • Business
    • Corporate
    • Economy & Trade
    • Stocks
    • Money
    • Agri & Mining
    • Power & Tech
    • IT & Telecom
  • Sports
    • Basketball
    • Volleyball
    • Fightsports
    • Active
    • Sports Plus
    • One Championship
    • Columns
  • Entertainment
    • TV & Movies
    • Celebrity Profiles
    • Music & Concerts
    • Digital Media
    • Columns
  • Lifestyle
    • Food
    • Culture & Media
    • Fashion
    • Health and Home
    • Leisure
    • Shopping
    • Columns
  • Others
    • Pets
    • Pop.Life
      • Newsmakers
      • Hangouts
      • A-Pop
      • Post Its
      • Performances
      • Malls & Bazaars
      • Hobbies & Collections
    • Technology
      • Gadgets
      • Computers
      • Business
      • Tech Plus
    • MS ON THE ROAD
      • Sedan
      • SUV
      • Truck
      • Bike
      • Accessories
      • Motoring Plus
      • Commuter’s Corner
    • Home & Design
      • Residential
      • Commercial
      • Construction
      • Interior
    • Spotlight
    • Gallery
      • Photos
      • Videos
    • Events
      • Seminars
      • Exhibits
      • Community
    • Biyahero
      • Travel Features
      • Travel Reels
      • Travel Logs
  • Advertise with Us
No Result
View All Result
manilastandard.net
No Result
View All Result
Home Opinion Columns About Town by Ernesto M. Hilario

Expert: Arbitral ruling on SCS can be reversed

Ernesto M. HilariobyErnesto M. Hilario
May 14, 2021, 12:05 am
in About Town by Ernesto M. Hilario
Reading Time: 4 mins read
A A
72
SHARES
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on Email

"Here are the thoughts of Oxford University professor Stefan Talmon."

 

Every now and then, the dispute between the Philippines and China over territorial and maritime claims in the South China Sea grabs newspaper headlines. The most recent one, of course, had to do with the presence of more than 200 Chinese vessels near the Julian Felipe Reef which prompted our Department of Foreign Affairs to fire off a barrage of diplomatic protests—one per day, according to Secretary Teodoro Locsin Jr.—and for the Philippine Coast Guard to send ships to the area to assert our sovereign rights over that part of the West Philippine Sea.

The dispute is not likely to be settled soon even as the two sides have established the Bilateral Consultation Mechanism (BCM) to discuss specific issues related to the conflicting claims. So far, the BCMs have met five times since 2017, but their joint statements after each meeting give us little indication that substantial agreements have been reached on key issues.

The Philippines insists on China's acceptance of the July 2016 ruling of the Permanent Court of Arbitration (PCA) established under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea or UNCLOS. Beijing does not recognize the validity of the PCA ruling—it refused to be part of it in the first place—and claims sovereignty over nearly all of the South China Sea based on what it calls the nine-dash line.

The Philippine position was clearly articulated by President Rodrigo Duterte before the United Nations General Assembly on September 22, 2020: “The award is now part of international law, beyond compromise and beyond the reach of passing governments to dilute, diminish or abandon.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Retired Chief Justice Artemio V. Panganiban clarifies, however, that while Unclos is a multilateral treaty and is part of international law, arbitral decisions such as that handed down by the PCA or other tribunals are, "as a rule, not parts of international law and are not precedents for future arbitrations…I do not wish to devalue arbitrations. As chair of the Philippine National Group in the PCA, I would be the last person to do that. I was just candidly stating a reality."

The views of the former Chief Justice regarding the nature of the arbitral ruling is consistent with the explanation offered by Oxford University professor Stefan Talmon, considered among the foremost experts on UNCLOS, along these lines:

"While the tribunal’s award in the South China Sea Arbitration is final in a procedural sense (procedural finality), it is not necessarily final with regard to the substantive issues involved (substantive finality). In other words, a ‘final award’ is the last award rendered on the issues in dispute between the parties; it is not necessarily the last word on the legal questions at issue. An arbitral award, as any decision by an international court or tribunal, does not cast international law in stone. Unlike most domestic legal systems international law does not know of a hierarchically organized judiciary with a single highest court at the apex. On the contrary, even the decisions of the ICJ (International Court of Justice) have no binding force except between the parties and in respect of the particular case at hand. The object of this provision is ‘to prevent legal principles accepted by the Court in a particular case from being binding also upon other States in other disputes’.

Talmon explains this in detail: "The structure of the international legal system and the fact that any decision rendered by an arbitral tribunal having compulsory jurisdiction under part XV, section 2 of the Unclos ‘shall have no binding force except between the parties and in respect of [the] particular dispute’ means that there are a number of ways in which the substantive finality of the arbitral award in the South China Sea Arbitration can be called into question."

One, judicial or arbitral pronouncements can be reversed by way of international legislation, either by the conclusion of an international treaty or by the creation of a rule of customary international law, which contradicts the finding of an international court or tribunal.

Two, judicial and arbitral pronouncements can be reversed through contrary State practice. When interpreting a treaty an international court or tribunal takes into account ‘any subsequent practice in the application of the treaty which establishes the agreement of the parties regarding its interpretation’.

Three, judicial and arbitral pronouncements on the interpretation or application of a treaty provision can be reversed through subsequent agreements between the parties regarding the interpretation or the application of its provisions.

And four, the finality of judicial and arbitral pronouncements can be called into question by other international courts and tribunals or by domestic courts adopting a different view on a certain legal question.

The professor concludes: While the award of 12 July 2016 may be the final decision in the arbitration between the Philippines and China concerning their disputes in the South China Sea, it is by no means the final word on the legal questions raised by these disputes.

Are we suggesting that the Philippines should drop its entitlements based on the arbitral ruling in the Hague? No, not at all. We could even file a case before the ICJ and try to get another favorable ruling on the same issue. I understand that former Associate Justice Antonio Carpio is considering taking this move. Will he? Let's wait and see.

ernhil@yahoo.com

Tags: ChinaDepartment of Foreign AffairsErnesto HilarioJulian Felipe ReefPermanent Court of ArbitrationPhilippinesSecretary Teodoro Locsin Jr.South China SeaUnclosUnited Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea
ADVERTISEMENT
Ernesto M. Hilario

Ernesto M. Hilario

Related Posts

UP proposals on foreign policy

byErnesto M. Hilario
June 24, 2022, 12:00 am
0
248
Denying Villafuerte justice

"The Philippines now finds itself in the midst of intensifying great power rivalry, particularly between the United States and China"...

Read more

UP proposals on local governance

byErnesto M. Hilario
June 22, 2022, 12:10 am
0
336
Denying Villafuerte justice

"While there has been improved access to maternal health services and a decrease in infant mortality, LGUs still struggle with...

Read more

UP’s proposed governance agenda

byErnesto M. Hilario
June 17, 2022, 12:10 am
0
502
Nullity of marriage: a defense in bigamy cases

"UP academics contend that politics in the Philippines is highly personalistic, with candidates relying on popularity, patronage and fear in...

Read more

What’s the US agenda?

byErnesto M. Hilario
June 15, 2022, 12:15 am
0
682
Denying Villafuerte justice

"One possible outcome of the detente is that the US could favorably consider the resumption of economic assistance to the...

Read more

What can we expect from the House?

byErnesto M. Hilario
June 10, 2022, 12:05 am
0
316
Denying Villafuerte justice

"House members will focus on bills seeking to boost employment generation and extend support to micro, small and medium enterprises...

Read more

What can we expect from today’s Senate?

byErnesto M. Hilario
June 8, 2022, 12:10 am
0
484
Denying Villafuerte justice

"The fundamental law does not require that those who aspire to become senators should have sterling reputations and unquestioned integrity"...

Read more

Stories you may like

  • Ex-Naga dad links Leni’s brother-in-law to illegal drugs

    Ex-Naga dad links Leni’s brother-in-law to illegal drugs

    36760 shares
    Share 14704 Tweet 9190
  • Of course, it was BBM’s project

    30882 shares
    Share 12353 Tweet 7721
  • INC endorses BBM, Sara

    28808 shares
    Share 11523 Tweet 7202
  • Duterte’s seven biggest achievements

    21981 shares
    Share 8792 Tweet 5495
  • Marcos leads SWS survey on presidentiables at 50%

    13583 shares
    Share 5433 Tweet 3396

Print Edition

View More

Recent Posts

  • 22 tagged in agri smuggling
  • Oil prices move closer to P100/l with new hikes
  • VP’s husband Emhoff leading US delegation to inauguration
  • COVID tally, serious cases going up
  • House planning 100% face-to-face SONA for Marcos, first in two years
  • Ople wants OFWs deployed quicker; Hospital workers too despite shortage
  • Duterte leaving as ‘most popular’ leader—survey
  • Fear, defiance for kin of drug war dead

Advertisement

Latest News

Ople wants OFWs deployed quicker; Hospital workers too despite shortage

byVito Barcelo
June 28, 2022, 12:50 am
0
145
Ople still undecided on DMW post

Incoming Department of Migrant Workers Secretary Susan Ople wants to hasten the processing of the deployment of overseas Filipino workers,...

Read more

Duterte leaving as ‘most popular’ leader—survey

byManila Standard
June 28, 2022, 12:40 am
0
150
Rody: I did my best to serve you, but sorry if you find that lacking

Outgoing President Rodrigo Duterte will step down from office as “the most popular president of the post-Edsa 1 era,” according...

Read more

Fear, defiance for kin of drug war dead

byCecil Morella
June 28, 2022, 12:30 am
0
150
Vax wastage, infection surge feared in Odette-hit areas

Six years after four policemen burst into her Manila slum shack and shot dead her husband and teenage son, Mary...

Read more

Enrile has COVID, will skip Marcos inaugural rites

byManila Standard
June 28, 2022, 12:20 am
0
151
El Shaddai adviser insists: Velarde’s endorsement of BBM-Sara ‘personal’

Incoming presidential legal counsel Juan Ponce Enrile has tested positive for COVID-19 and will skip the inauguration of President-elect Ferdinand...

Read more

Good going to CHED commissioner

byManila Standard
June 28, 2022, 12:15 am
0
145
Good going to CHED commissioner

More than a week back, Commission on Higher Education Commissioner Dr. Ronald Adamat formally received the Mahatma MK Gandhi Peace...

Read more

Advertisement

ADVERTISEMENT
Facebook Twitter Instagram Youtube

ABOUT US

Manila Standard

Manila Standard website (manilastandard.net), launched in August 2002, extends the newspaper’s reach beyond its traditional readers and makes its brand of Philippine news and opinion available to a much wider and geographically diverse readership here and overseas.

Digital Edition

In tone and content, the online edition mirrors the editorial thrust of the newspaper. While hewing to the traditional precepts of fairness and objectivity, MS believes the news of the day need not be staid, overly long or dry. Stories are succinct, readable and written in a lively style that has become a hallmark of the newspaper.

Download – Today’s Paper

Search

No Result
View All Result

6th Floor Universal Re Bldg., 106 Paseo De Roxas cor. Perea Street, Legaspi Village, 1226 Makati City Philippines

Trunklines: 832-5554, 832-5556, 832-5558

© 2021 Manila Standard - Designed and Developed by Neitiviti Studios.

No Result
View All Result
  • About
  • News
    • Top Stories
    • National
    • World News
    • Pinoy Abroad
    • Features
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
    • Columns
    • Soundbytes
  • LGUs
    • NCR
    • Luzon
    • Visayas
    • Mindanao
  • Business
    • Corporate
    • Economy & Trade
    • Stocks
    • Money
    • Agri & Mining
    • Power & Tech
    • IT & Telecom
  • Sports
    • Basketball
    • Volleyball
    • Fightsports
    • Active
    • Sports Plus
    • One Championship
    • Columns
  • Entertainment
    • TV & Movies
    • Celebrity Profiles
    • Music & Concerts
    • Digital Media
    • Columns
  • Lifestyle
    • Food
    • Culture & Media
    • Fashion
    • Health and Home
    • Leisure
    • Shopping
    • Columns
  • Pop.Life
    • Newsmakers
    • Hangouts
    • A-Pop
    • Post Its
    • Performances
    • Malls & Bazaars
    • Hobbies & Collections
  • Technology
    • Gadgets
    • Computers
    • Business
    • Tech Plus
  • MS ON THE ROAD
    • Sedan
    • SUV
    • Truck
    • Bike
    • Accessories
    • Motoring Plus
    • Commuter’s Corner
  • Home & Design
    • Residential
    • Commercial
    • Construction
    • Interior
  • Spotlight
  • Gallery
    • Photos
    • Videos
  • Events
    • Seminars
    • Exhibits
    • Community
  • Biyahero
    • Travel Features
    • Travel Reels
    • Travel Logs
  • Pets
  • Advertise with Us

© 2021 Manila Standard - Designed and Developed by Neitiviti Studios.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Install Manila Standard Web App

Install App