Tuesday, August 9, 2022
manilastandard.net
ADVERTISEMENT
  • About
  • News
    • Top Stories
    • National
    • World News
    • Pinoy Abroad
    • Features
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
    • Columns
    • Soundbytes
  • LGUs
    • NCR
    • Luzon
    • Visayas
    • Mindanao
  • Business
    • Corporate
    • Economy & Trade
    • Stocks
    • Money
    • Agri & Mining
    • Power & Tech
    • IT & Telecom
  • Sports
    • Basketball
    • Volleyball
    • Fightsports
    • Active
    • Sports Plus
    • One Championship
    • Columns
  • Entertainment
    • TV & Movies
    • Celebrity Profiles
    • Music & Concerts
    • Digital Media
    • Columns
  • Lifestyle
    • Food
    • Culture & Media
    • Fashion
    • Health and Home
    • Leisure
    • Shopping
    • Columns
  • Others
    • Pets
    • Pop.Life
      • Newsmakers
      • Hangouts
      • A-Pop
      • Post Its
      • Performances
      • Malls & Bazaars
      • Hobbies & Collections
    • Technology
      • Gadgets
      • Computers
      • Business
      • Tech Plus
    • MS ON THE ROAD
      • Sedan
      • SUV
      • Truck
      • Bike
      • Accessories
      • Motoring Plus
      • Commuter’s Corner
    • Home & Design
      • Residential
      • Commercial
      • Construction
      • Interior
    • Spotlight
    • Gallery
      • Photos
      • Videos
    • Events
      • Seminars
      • Exhibits
      • Community
    • Biyahero
      • Travel Features
      • Travel Reels
      • Travel Logs
  • Advertise with Us
No Result
View All Result
  • About
  • News
    • Top Stories
    • National
    • World News
    • Pinoy Abroad
    • Features
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
    • Columns
    • Soundbytes
  • LGUs
    • NCR
    • Luzon
    • Visayas
    • Mindanao
  • Business
    • Corporate
    • Economy & Trade
    • Stocks
    • Money
    • Agri & Mining
    • Power & Tech
    • IT & Telecom
  • Sports
    • Basketball
    • Volleyball
    • Fightsports
    • Active
    • Sports Plus
    • One Championship
    • Columns
  • Entertainment
    • TV & Movies
    • Celebrity Profiles
    • Music & Concerts
    • Digital Media
    • Columns
  • Lifestyle
    • Food
    • Culture & Media
    • Fashion
    • Health and Home
    • Leisure
    • Shopping
    • Columns
  • Others
    • Pets
    • Pop.Life
      • Newsmakers
      • Hangouts
      • A-Pop
      • Post Its
      • Performances
      • Malls & Bazaars
      • Hobbies & Collections
    • Technology
      • Gadgets
      • Computers
      • Business
      • Tech Plus
    • MS ON THE ROAD
      • Sedan
      • SUV
      • Truck
      • Bike
      • Accessories
      • Motoring Plus
      • Commuter’s Corner
    • Home & Design
      • Residential
      • Commercial
      • Construction
      • Interior
    • Spotlight
    • Gallery
      • Photos
      • Videos
    • Events
      • Seminars
      • Exhibits
      • Community
    • Biyahero
      • Travel Features
      • Travel Reels
      • Travel Logs
  • Advertise with Us
No Result
View All Result
manilastandard.net
No Result
View All Result
Home Opinion Columns Eagle eyes by Tony La Vina

The Ilagan and Brocka Cases

Tony La ViñabyTony La Viña
February 20, 2016, 12:01 am
in Eagle eyes by Tony La Vina
Reading Time: 4 mins read
A A
88
SHARES
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on Email

This is the second of three columns on Supreme Court decisions that have Senator Juan Ponce Enrile as a protagonist, either as a respondent accused of violating the human rights of citizens or as a petitioner invoking constitutional rights against the state. In the cases I discuss in this column, Ilagan vs. Enrile and Brocka vs. Enrile, as he was in the Aquino and Padilla cases discussed in the first column of this series, the senator is the principal respondent as defense secretary and minister of defense of the Marcos dictatorship.

In 1985, Attorney Laurente C. Ilagan was arrested in Davao City by elements of the PC-INP and detained at Camp Catitipan on the basis of a Mission Order allegedly issued by the Ministry of National Defense. Subsequently, two other lawyers were arrested and detained on the basis of a Mission Order.

A petition for habeas corpus was filed by and on behalf of the three detained attorneys on the ground that their arrests were illegal and violative of the Constitution, since arrests cannot be made on the basis of Mission Orders and that there appears to be a military campaign to harass lawyers involved in national security cases. The petition also contended that their detention was improper arrest, and that no preliminary investigation has been conducted.

 In this case, the government argued that the detained attorneys were arrested on the basis of a Preventive Detention Action (PDA) issued by the President on Jan. 25, 1985; that the Writ of habeas corpus is suspended as to them by virtue of Proclamation No. 2045-A. Subsequently, they further argued that the petition for habeas corpus had been rendered moot and academic by virtue of the filing of an Information against them for Rebellion, a capital offense, before the Regional Trial Court of Davao City and the issuance of a Warrant of Arrest against the three detainees.

In a unanimous decision, the Court, through Justice Ameurfina Melencio-Herrera, stated that the remedy is not a petition for a Writ of Habeas Corpus but a Motion before the trial court to quash the Warrant of Arrest, and/or the Information on grounds provided by the Rules or to ask for an investigation/reinvestigation of the case. The Court further stated that habeas corpus would not lie after the Warrant of Commitment was issued by the Court on the basis of the Information filed against the accused.

ADVERTISEMENT

As a result, the petition for Habeas Corpus was dismissed for having become moot and academic. The Court pronounced that the three detainees were now detained by virtue of a Warrant of Arrest issued by the Regional Trial Court of Davao City in relation to the criminal case for Rebellion filed against them before said court.

The Ilagan doctrine has been roundly criticized for being anti-democratic. Unfortunately, it is still routinely invoked by prosecutors to justify detention of accused even when the original arrests were illegal. A few years ago, in the celebrated case involving 43 health workers illegally arrested in Morong, Rizal, the Court of Appeals justified the workers’ continuing detention citing this unfortunate precedent.

The Ilagan decision, rendered in 1985, was one of the last decisions of the Supreme Court before the Edsa revolution.

The Brocka vs. Enrile case, decided in 1990 by a different Supreme Court, illustrates the change of regime and what a difference democracy makes.

The case started on Jan. 28, 1985 when movie director Lino Brocka and theater director Behn Cervantes, both icons in their artistic fields, were arrested along with their companions (this included Howie Severino of GMA-7, then a teacher at the Ateneo de Manila High School), were arrested by elements of the Northern Police District following the forcible and violent dispersal of a demonstration held in sympathy with the jeepney strike called by the Alliance of Concerned Transport Organization (ACTO). Thereafter, they were charged with Illegal Assembly before the RTC-Quezon City. Without prior notice to their counsel, Brocka, et al. were subsequently charged with Inciting to Sedition.  

In their petition for habeas corpus, Brocka, et al. as petitioners, contended that respondents’ manifest bad faith and/or harassment are sufficient bases for enjoining their criminal prosecution, aside from the fact that the second offense of inciting to sedition is illegal, since it is premised on one and the same act of attending and participating in the ACTO jeepney strike. They maintain that while there may  have been a complex crime from a single act (Art. 48, RTC), the law does not allow the splitting of a single act into two offenses and filing two informations therefor, further, that they will be placed in double jeopardy.

The main issue raised before the Supreme Court was the legality of enjoining the criminal prosecution of a case. And in a unanimous decision, the Court granted the petition and enjoined the criminal prosecution of Brocka et al. for the second offense of inciting to sedition.

According to the Court, Brocka, et al. have clearly shown the circumstances to show that the criminal proceedings had become a case of persecution, having been undertaken by state officials in bad faith. The Court added that the hasty filing of the second offense, premised on a spurious and inoperational PDA, certainly betrayed the respondent’s bad faith and malicious intent to pursue criminal charges against Brocka, et al. It further noted—“. . . the tenacious invocation of a spurious and inoperational PDA and the sham and hasty preliminary investigation were clear signals that the prosecutors intended to keep Brocka, et al. in detention until the second offense of “Inciting to Sedition” could be facilitated and justified without need of issuing a warrant of arrest anew.”  

I have a personal story about the Brocka case. One of those arrested with the film director was Al Alegre, a close friend and house mate at the “House of Being,” an apartment in Katipunan Avenue that several of us philosophy teachers, students and alumni shared in the early 1980s. Because Al was also detained, I attended the bail hearings in that case and was able to witness two great women lawyers—Judge Miriam Defensor Santiago and defense counsel Haydee Yorac, both also UP Law professors at that time—in action. That experience inspired me to take up law and to become a human rights lawyer.

In the next column, I will summarize two cases where, this time, we see a twist: Minister Enrile, no longer the martial law administrator, now invokes constitutional rights that were denied those he had custody of during the Marcos years. Enrile vs. Salazar and Enrile vs. Sandiganbayan are the names of those cases and the lessons they impart says a lot about rule of law, or lack of it, in the Philippines.

Facebook: Dean Tony La Vina Twitter: tonylavs 

Tags: Dean Tony La ViñaJuan Ponce EnrileLaurente C. IlaganLino BrockaThe Ilagan and Brocka Cases
ADVERTISEMENT
Tony La Viña

Tony La Viña

Related Posts

Gilbert Son, missionary of hope

byTony La Viña
August 9, 2022, 12:05 am
0
157
Denying Villafuerte justice

"It is important to have an adult itinerary of faith, so that believers, with the grace of God, step by...

Read more

FVR’s template of good governance

byTony La Viña
August 6, 2022, 12:10 am
0
339
Denying Villafuerte justice

"FVR reminds us that we can be a great country and not the bickering, conflict-driven, and disunited nation that Marcos,...

Read more

Sickness unto death

byTony La Viña
August 2, 2022, 12:05 am
0
881
Denying Villafuerte justice

"I protest the suffering and deaths of my friends but I am also surprised by the beauty of their lives...

Read more

Terrible disinformation on Furigay killing

byTony La Viña
July 30, 2022, 12:05 am
0
1.3k
Hold the line together

"There is no justification for what suspect Dr. Chiao Tiao Yumul did and it must be condemned by all men...

Read more

Interesting first Sona by Marcos

byTony La Viña
July 26, 2022, 12:05 am
0
1.1k
Denying Villafuerte justice

"The president also took note of the increase in household consumption as the country continues to reopen, along with robust...

Read more

High expectations for Marcos’ first SONA

byTony La Viña
July 25, 2022, 12:15 am
0
504
Denying Villafuerte justice

"His administration will grapple with a wide variety of challenges, problems and issues, now existing or may yet emerge in...

Read more
ADVERTISEMENT
Facebook Twitter Instagram Youtube

ABOUT US

Manila Standard

Manila Standard website (manilastandard.net), launched in August 2002, extends the newspaper’s reach beyond its traditional readers and makes its brand of Philippine news and opinion available to a much wider and geographically diverse readership here and overseas.

Digital Edition

In tone and content, the online edition mirrors the editorial thrust of the newspaper. While hewing to the traditional precepts of fairness and objectivity, MS believes the news of the day need not be staid, overly long or dry. Stories are succinct, readable and written in a lively style that has become a hallmark of the newspaper.

Download – Today’s Paper

Search

No Result
View All Result

6th Floor Universal Re Bldg., 106 Paseo De Roxas cor. Perea Street, Legaspi Village, 1226 Makati City Philippines

Trunklines: 832-5554, 832-5556, 832-5558

© 2021 Manila Standard - Designed and Developed by Neitiviti Studios.

No Result
View All Result
  • About
  • News
    • Top Stories
    • National
    • World News
    • Pinoy Abroad
    • Features
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
    • Columns
    • Soundbytes
  • LGUs
    • NCR
    • Luzon
    • Visayas
    • Mindanao
  • Business
    • Corporate
    • Economy & Trade
    • Stocks
    • Money
    • Agri & Mining
    • Power & Tech
    • IT & Telecom
  • Sports
    • Basketball
    • Volleyball
    • Fightsports
    • Active
    • Sports Plus
    • One Championship
    • Columns
  • Entertainment
    • TV & Movies
    • Celebrity Profiles
    • Music & Concerts
    • Digital Media
    • Columns
  • Lifestyle
    • Food
    • Culture & Media
    • Fashion
    • Health and Home
    • Leisure
    • Shopping
    • Columns
  • Pop.Life
    • Newsmakers
    • Hangouts
    • A-Pop
    • Post Its
    • Performances
    • Malls & Bazaars
    • Hobbies & Collections
  • Technology
    • Gadgets
    • Computers
    • Business
    • Tech Plus
  • MS ON THE ROAD
    • Sedan
    • SUV
    • Truck
    • Bike
    • Accessories
    • Motoring Plus
    • Commuter’s Corner
  • Home & Design
    • Residential
    • Commercial
    • Construction
    • Interior
  • Spotlight
  • Gallery
    • Photos
    • Videos
  • Events
    • Seminars
    • Exhibits
    • Community
  • Biyahero
    • Travel Features
    • Travel Reels
    • Travel Logs
  • Pets
  • Advertise with Us

© 2021 Manila Standard - Designed and Developed by Neitiviti Studios.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Install Manila Standard Web App

Install App