Tuesday, November 10, 2026

Today's Print

Mr. President, do not choose a shield

“Mr. President, skipping the seniors for Zalameda will cost you the protection you seek”

Chief Justice Alexander Gesmundo retires on Nov. 6, and reports suggest that some in Malacañang are urging President Bongbong Marcos to bypass the Court’s most senior justices and appoint Associate Justice Rodil Zalameda as Chief Justice.

Appointed only in 2019, Zalameda is seventh in seniority.

- Advertisement -

Passing over more senior, highly qualified justices, many of whom already chair divisions of the Court, will inevitably be viewed as an attempt at political insurance.

The President should understand that the public will see it that way, and the strategy is unlikely to deliver the protection its advocates imagine.

The reason is obvious. Justice Zalameda authored two Supreme Court decisions of major significance to the President’s family.

In 2023, he wrote the en banc ruling dismissing the P41-billion ill-gotten wealth case against the Marcoses and Lucio Tan.

This year, he penned the First Division decision that reversed Imelda Marcos’s 2018 graft conviction and acquitted her on seven counts.

No one is claiming these rulings lacked legal basis. Both rested on findings regarding insufficient or inadmissible evidence. But politics is often about perception.

If the President elevates the author of both decisions to the judiciary’s highest post, many will see it as a reward. Such a move would not strengthen those rulings. It would cast a shadow over decisions that should stand entirely on their legal merits.

We have seen a similar situation before. In 2012, Maria Lourdes Sereno was appointed Chief Justice after only two years on the Supreme Court, leapfrogging more senior figures such as Acting Chief Justice Antonio Carpio.

The appointment never gained full acceptance within the Court.

During the impeachment proceedings against Sereno, sitting justices testified against their own Chief Justice before the House of Representatives.

The controversy ultimately culminated in Republic v. Sereno. The lesson remains clear: shortcuts leave lasting institutional scars.

Running the Supreme Court is not the same as running a Cabinet department. In the executive branch, presidents may appoint loyalists because agencies operate through a clear chain of command.

The Court functions differently.

Fifteen independent justices cannot simply be directed from above.

Seniority serves as an important source of legitimacy and cohesion.

A Chief Justice who has risen through the ranks carries the respect of colleagues and possesses the influence needed to build consensus and guide the institution.

Bypassing senior division chairs for a junior appointee sends a damaging message, not only within the Court but throughout the judiciary: that loyalty matters more than merit.

Some advisers may believe that a personally loyal Chief Justice can serve as a safeguard after a president leaves office.

That belief misunderstands how the Court works.

The Chief Justice has only one vote out of 15. He cannot command other members of the Court. His influence depends largely on the respect he commands among his peers.

Yet respect is exactly what becomes more difficult to secure when an appointment is widely perceived as politically motivated.

Justices who have spent decades building distinguished careers are unlikely to defer automatically to a colleague elevated through political favor.

History repeatedly challenges the assumption that appointees remain loyal to those who appoint them. Political power is temporary. When it disappears, so often do the benefits of personal alliances.

Moreover, a Chief Justice remains on the bench until mandatory retirement at age 70, often serving long after a new administration takes office.

An appointee perceived as indebted to a president faces an impossible position.

If he rules in favor of that president, critics will allege repayment of a political debt. If he rules against him, then the supposed value of the appointment disappears. Either way, the president gains little.

In the final years of this administration, the Supreme Court will likely confront politically sensitive and consequential cases.

What the country needs is a stable, credible Court, not a Chief Justice viewed by colleagues and the public as a political beneficiary.

What ultimately protects any former president is not personal loyalty but institutional legitimacy.

Public trust rests on the belief that the Court acts independently and decides cases according to law.

Mr. President, look first for a jurist with integrity, sound judicial philosophy, and a demonstrated commitment to the Filipino people, particularly the marginalized.

Choose the most senior eligible justice who embodies those qualities. Doing so would strengthen the Court, reinforce confidence in its independence, and leave behind a judicial legacy that cannot easily be questioned.

What protects an outgoing president is a Chief Justice whose authority comes from professional excellence and the respect of colleagues, not from the favor of the appointing power.

Such a leader will decide cases based solely on law and evidence, including those involving former presidents and their families. That is the only protection worth having.

Mr. President, do not choose a shield. Choose a Chief Justice whom both the Court and the nation can respect. (Email:ernhil@yahoo.com)

- Advertisement -

Leave a review

RECENT STORIES

spot_imgspot_imgspot_imgspot_img
Scroll to play
spot_img
spot_imgspot_imgspot_img
Popular Categories
- Advertisement -spot_img