THE Philippines said Thursday it is in talks with a Chinese state firm for joint South China Sea energy resource exploration and extraction, in a proposed deal described by President Rodrigo Duterte as akin to “co-ownership” of contested areas.
The two countries have long been embroiled in a bitter dispute over their competing claims to the region—with China claiming nearly the entire sea—but Duterte has in recent years softened his predecessors’ policy of opposing Beijing’s claims.
Duterte said Wednesday an arrangement to turn two of the rival claimants virtual joint owners of the strategic and supposedly oil and gas-rich sea was preferable to the “massacre” of Filipino troops in a war with China.
“Now their [Beijing’s] offer is joint exploration, which is like co-ownership. It’s like the two of us would be the owners. I think that’s better than fighting,” he said during a visit to the war-torn southern city of Marawi.
Negotiations between the Philippines and China over South China Sea exploration were raised last month by Filipino Foreign Secretary Alan Peter Cayetano.
Presidential Spokesman Harry Roque provided more detail Thursday, specifying that talks were underway between the Philippines’ Energy Department and an unnamed Chinese state firm, and that extraction of energy resources was now on the table.
He did not specify which specific area of the sea was under discussion.
Brunei, Malaysia, Taiwan and Vietnam also claim all or part of the sea. Proposed cooperation between Manila and Beijing has caused alarm among neighboring Southeast Asian countries in the past.
“We might enter into an agreement with a Chinese-owned corporation, not the Chinese state itself,” Roque said in an interview aired on ABS-CBN television, adding the company he declined to name was state-owned.
“I know that they’re discussing, they’re moving forward and it’s likely to happen,” he added without giving a timetable or the exact terms of the proposed deal.
“This will now actually entail joint exploration and possible exploitation of natural resources.”
Duterte’s willingness to cooperate with China marks a turnaround from predecessor Benigno Aquino III’s stance accusing Beijing of encroaching, occupying, and building structures on reefs and rocks that Manila claims as part of its exclusive economic zone.
The Philippines won an international arbitration tribunal ruling in 2016 invalidating Beijing’s claims, but Duterte set aside the ruling while courting investments and trade from the Philippines’ giant neighbor, the world’s second-largest economy.
Cayetano said last month that Manila would consult legal experts to make sure any accord would not infringe on Philippine sovereign rights. With AFP
“It’s not that we have no choice. We can go back and say, ‘Fine, no one benefits from the resources now’. But come on, we’re trying to look for alternative sources of energy,” Roque said Thursday.
He said Filipino firms could not do it on their own and would need Chinese capital, while noting that “when a Filipino company attempted to explore on its own they were met by Chinese warboats [gunboats].”
He was referring to a 2011 incident when Manila said Chinese patrol boats harassed a seismic survey vessel chartered by a unit of a Philippine mining company at Philippine-claimed Reed Bank in the South China Sea.
Magdalo Party-list Rep. Gary Alejano on Thursday asked the Supreme Court to rule on a petition questioning the constitutionality of the Joint Marine Seismic Undertaking with China and Vietnam.
The JMSU is a joint seismic exploration agreement entered into by the Philippines with China and Vietnam in 2005. It covers 80 percent of the Kalayaan Group of Islands and the Reed Bank.
The JMSU was recently brought to the fore once more when Cayetano used it as s precedent amid talk of joint exploration with China in the West Philippine Sea.
Alejano’s resolution asked the Court to update Congress on the status of the JMSU petition, and emphasized the importance of settling its constitutionality.
“A final ruling by the Supreme Court regarding the constitutionality of the JMSU would be most vital in determining the Philippine’s foreign policy direction, its subsequent dealings with China and any other foreign states seeking to partner for marine exploration and resource exploitation, and the policy directives of the Congress,” Alejano said.
“Given the seeming enthusiasm of the Duterte administration in pursuing a joint exploration with China, I urge the Supreme Court to hasten the resolution of the petition,” he added.
Former chief justice Hilario Davide Jr., meanwhile, said Chinese leaders would not consider as a joke Duterte’s suggestion that the Philippines become a province of China.
“China is practically flying its flag on the West Philippine Sea, and is trying to grab our Benham Rise,” Davide said.
“Last February 19, before Chinese businessmen, the President mentioned of the Philippines as a province of China. Malacanang spokesperson Harry Roque explained that it was just a joke of the President. But China will not consider it a joke. Chinese leaders are not known to be jokers,” he added. With AFP