Recognized loan proceeds, renewed time deposits and transfers between the couple’s own accounts were excluded before the prosecution’s financial analyst calculated the questioned personal-income inflows involving Vice President Sara Duterte and her husband, lawyer Manases Carpio.
House trial spokesperson Zia Alonto Adiong of Lanao del Sur detailed the exclusions, explaining why bank deposits and new earnings should be distinguished when examining the couple’s finances.
Among the excluded transactions were the alleged P8 million in housing-loan proceeds, P102 million in time-deposit rollovers, P10.29 million and P5 million in investment proceeds, and P72.18 million transferred between their own accounts. “This is not income; it is a loan,” Alonto Adiong said of the loan proceeds.
He said forensic financial analyst Atty. Alexander Cabrera sought to examine money allegedly entering the accounts without counting recognized movements of existing funds as fresh income. Alonto Adiong also argued that a Statement of Assets, Liabilities and Net Worth (SALN) provides only a year-end snapshot and does not reflect all transactions throughout the year.
A December 31 balance, therefore, does not by itself establish the full year’s receipts or the purpose of payments made earlier. Alonto Adiong said the review required transaction records alongside the amounts remaining at year-end, including the financial activities of any companies owned by the individuals concerned.
The panel compared the remaining identified inflows with the income declared in the couple’s tax returns. Alonto Adiong presented Cabrera’s original four-year comparison under Article II, which covers alleged unexplained wealth, asset disclosures and business interests. The exclusions formed part of the methodology used in assessing the income comparison.







