Kids score landmark victory in bid to block Australian coal mine

posted May 30, 2021 at 07:20 pm
by  AFP
Sydney—Teenagers suing to block expansion of an c coal mine scored a “landmark” victory Thursday, with a judge agreeing the project would cause them climate-related harm.

A group of eight high-schoolers—backed by an activist octogenarian nun—brought a class action against Australia’s pro-coal conservative government over a planned mine extension near Sydney.

While a federal judge rejected the group’s calls for an injunction to stop the project outright, he ruled the government must take into account the damage the project would do to the group’s health, wealth and wellbeing.

“The minister has a duty to take reasonable care to avoid causing personal injury to the children when deciding... to approve or not approve the extension project,” Justice Mordy  Bromberg found.

Legal experts said the ruling was significant because it was the first time a court had accepted expert testimony about the vast potential impact of climate change on younger generations and the government’s duty to consider that impact in weighing new fossil fuel projects.

In the ruling, Bromberg accepted harrowing expert evidence of a grim future on a warming planet.

It was, he said, “what  might fairly be described as the greatest inter-generational  injustice  ever inflicted by one generation of humans upon the next.”

“It is not merely the vulnerability of the children which I find potent. It is also their innocence. They bear no responsibility for the unparalleled predicament which they now face,” he said.

Ava Princi, a 17-year-old litigant, described the judgment as a “thrilling” world-first victory for young people that should inspire further action.

“This is a landmark decision. This is the first time a court of law, anywhere in the world, has recognized that a government minister has a duty of care to protect young people from the catastrophic harms of climate change,” she said.

“This case was about young people stepping up and demanding more from the adults whose actions are determining our future wellbeing,” she added.

“I hope that this case inspires more of us, everywhere in the world, to push for stronger, faster and deeper cuts to carbon emissions.”

Courts are increasingly becoming the front line in battles over the future of the planet.  

A Dutch court on Wednesday ordered oil giant Shell to slash its greenhouse gas emissions in a landmark victory for climate activists with implications for energy firms worldwide. 

The fate of the Australian project—Whitehaven Coal’s Vickery Extension—is yet to be decided.

Judge Bromberg said he would reserve orders “for later consideration” after the parties confer.  

The Australian high school students had hoped the case would create a precedent that would virtually rule out the construction of any new fossil fuel projects. 

Topics: Australia , Coal Mine , Whitehaven Coal , Mordy Bromberg , climate change
COMMENT DISCLAIMER: Reader comments posted on this Web site are not in any way endorsed by The Standard. Comments are views by readers who exercise their right to free expression and they do not necessarily represent or reflect the position or viewpoint of While reserving this publication’s right to delete comments that are deemed offensive, indecent or inconsistent with The Standard editorial standards, The Standard may not be held liable for any false information posted by readers in this comments section.