Two internationally-recognized economists said the Philippine government could boost revenue, reduce smoking rates and curb illicit trade by adopting fair, risk-based taxation for smoke-free nicotine products such as vapes, heated tobacco and nicotine pouches.
Laffer Associates founder and chairman Dr. Arthur Laffer said the Philippine government should adopt data-driven taxation policies that balance fiscal sustainability with public health goals.
“Find that sweet spot where you have just the right taxation, you discourage as many smokers as possible without losing them to illicit tobacco, and you collect revenues to implement [tobacco control] programs,” he said.
Laffer previously served as a member of President Ronald Reagan’s Economic Policy Advisory Board and is known as the architect of the Laffer Curve, a theory that illustrates the relationship between tax rates and government revenue.
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) former German delegate Prof. Ashok Kaul said countries that lowered their smoking rates significantly implemented simplified, risk-proportionate tax systems that encourage consumers to move away from combustible cigarettes toward reduced-risk alternatives. Kaul also served as lead scientist on Double Taxation Agreements for the German Ministry of Finance.
Kaul said maintaining a significant tax rate differential between cigarettes and smoke-free alternatives creates strong incentives for smokers to switch.
Laffer said smoke-free nicotine products play an important role in reducing tobacco-related harm by offering less hazardous options for people who struggle to quit using conventional therapies. “Set a lower tax for such products to encourage more smokers to switch to less harmful alternatives,” he said.
Kaul cited Sweden’s risk-proportionate tax framework, which maintains differentiated rates for smoke-free alternatives and combustible cigarettes, as a model.
He said the approach reduced smoking prevalence in Sweden from 15 percent to 5.3 percent over 15 years, positioning the country to become the world’s first smoke-free nation. Tobacco-related mortality in Sweden remains far below the European average, with Swedish men recording some of the lowest smoking-related disease rates in the European Union.
“Many Swedes stopped smoking, but even more switched [to smoke-free alternatives]. And now Sweden has, among the European countries, the lowest lung cancer rate by far. So, you can see what good policies can achieve,” Kaul said.
Laffer warned that the Philippines’ annual excise tax hikes have contributed to declining government revenues and fueled growth in illicit tobacco trade. He cited research from the University of Asia and the Pacific (UA&P) confirming a strong correlation between stricter tobacco regulations and expansion of the illegal cigarette market.
“The data strongly suggest that the Philippines has gone too far in increasing tobacco tax rates. If you overtax a product, you lose control of the market, you lose revenues, you have more people buying illicit cigarettes,” he said.
Laffer pointed to Ireland as an example of similar outcomes, noting that steep annual increases in tobacco excise taxes there coincided with falling government revenues and a surge in customs seizures of illicit cigarettes, while smoking prevalence remained unchanged during the period.
Kaul said combining risk-proportionate taxation of smoke-free alternatives with strong enforcement measures can stimulate industry innovation, encourage consumers to shift away from combustible cigarettes and weaken illicit trade.
“Industry innovation is only possible if the illicit market is controlled. When innovative smoke-free nicotine products are available in the legitimate market, more consumers will be encouraged to switch to less harmful alternatives,” he said.







