Even as driving ban takes effect, Germany still clings to diesel

Hamburg  on Thursday became the first German city to ban older diesel vehicles from some highly polluted roads as public confidence in the once-loved technology goes up in smoke.

A 1,600-metre (one mile) stretch of highway and a 580-metre section of another major road will be closed to older diesels.

The port city is the first to act on a court ruling that such bans were a legitimate way for local authorities to reduce air pollution below European Union health thresholds.

Judges at the Federal Administrative Court found in February that cities could “gradually” eliminate diesel vehicles, starting with the oldest, while allowing exceptions including for emergency services, local residents and businesses.

“Germany has to do something” to improve air quality, said 37-year-old Sabine, who works on the Max-Brauer Allee, one of the roads hit by the ban.

Rudolf  Diesel,  inventor of the diesel engine.
“We should abolish diesels,” she added.

The cities of Stuttgart in the south and Kiel in the north are mulling their own diesel restrictions in the battle against air pollution, while Munich, Cologne and Duesseldorf are closely monitoring the Hamburg experiment.

Diesel was long seen by Germans as a proudly homegrown technology that could help battle climate change, with lower emissions of greenhouse gas carbon dioxide (CO2) than petrol motors.

Patented by Bavarian engineer Rudolf Diesel in 1892, the fuel is subsidised to this day in a number of European countries.

But its reputation has lain in tatters since Volkswagen’s “dieselgate” scandal broke in 2015.

Lip service 

The mammoth carmaker admitted to fitting millions of cars worldwide with “defeat devices” -- software designed to trick regulators into thinking cars met emissions standards.

In fact, output of harmful fine particulates and nitrogen oxides (NOx), which can cause respiratory and heart diseases, was far higher than legally permitted.

Diesel’s share of new car sales plunged from 47.7 percent in 2015 to 38.7 percent last year.

Nevertheless, Germany’s federal government under Chancellor Angela Merkel has often appeared to take the car industry’s side.

It has pushed back against diesel bans and rejects the idea of a “blue badge” drivers could stick on their windscreens that would identify the least polluting vehicles.

Instead, Berlin has offered longer-term measures like a cash pot to extend public transport and build up cities’ electric vehicle fleets.

That makes measures like those in Hamburg “just lip service from the politicians... I don’t think it will actually affect anything” said Felix Fischer, 49, who works in a bicycle shop on the Stresemannstrasse highway -- the other stretch to be closed to diesels.

Diesel ‘a German child’

Some media have dubbed leader Merkel the “Autokanzlerin” or car chancellor, playing on her concern to protect a critical sector for the German economy.

With some 600,000 jobs dependent on the internal combustion engine according to estimates from the Ifo economic institute in Munich, the chancellor’s centre-left coalition partners are just as concerned as Merkel’s conservatives to keep the technology alive.

Many such jobs would not be replaced if the industry switches to less mechanically complex electric power en masse.

Consulting firm SMP found firms can produce around 350 combustion engines per worker per year, a figure that rises to 1,600 for electric drivetrains. 

Diesel is “a German child that we’d rather not allow to die”, said Stefan Bratzel of the Centre of Automotive Management.

Bosch, the world’s biggest auto components supplier, trumpeted in April new technologies it claimed could “drastically” reduce diesel emissions and “put a stop, once and for all, to the debate about the demise of diesel technology”.

But the long-term effect of government and business prevarications could actually be to undermine the German car industry, argued Ferdinand Dudenhoeffer of the Centre for Automotive Research. 

Topics: Hamburg , Germany , Federal Administrative Court , Max-Brauer Allee , Angela Merkel , Diesel , Stefan Bratzel

Related stories:

No related stories matched this topic.

COMMENT DISCLAIMER: Reader comments posted on this Web site are not in any way endorsed by Manila Standard. Comments are views by readers who exercise their right to free expression and they do not necessarily represent or reflect the position or viewpoint of While reserving this publication’s right to delete comments that are deemed offensive, indecent or inconsistent with Manila Standard editorial standards, Manila Standard may not be held liable for any false information posted by readers in this comments section.